Chicken, Egg or Barnyard?

In the last class we spent some time discussing the various definitions of Web 2.0 and debating the how and where some of the Web 2.0, SMS, Social networking puzzle pieces all fit together.  I remember flashing in one moment of the discussion to the timeless question of which came first – chicken or egg?  Luckily as the discussion went on, I was able to advance this simple mental model to a more academic mindset of the discussion which led me back to readings by Gieryn (1999).  I have been pondering these writings for a few weeks now, and in the context of Web 2.0, they offer an alternative view for the discussion of defining the elements the social media domain.  Let me explain…

Perhaps an alternative to a Venn diagram to display the elements of Web 2.0, we could conceive of a cartographic diagram… simply put – a MAP!   Why is this an alternative worth considering?  Well, it not only allows us to consider the relative connection of Web 2.0 elements (chicken to egg), but also allows us to consider where the chicken and egg might reside in relation to each other (in the barnyard vs. in the hen-house) and draw comparisons to other yet to be developed Web 2.0 platforms, widgets, apps,  et. – or the NON Web 2.0 world (TV, Phone, face-2-face discussion, Web 1.0…). 

Cartography can also help us consider what kind of people and cultures might reside in the various map locations, by using the topography of the map to develop mental metaphors for the “local peoples” dwelling places.  The most wonderful thing about maps, is they are never wrong and also never completely right either; they are created through a unique perspective, but it is only one perspective.  They can change with the view of the beholder, or the change of times – they can become useful artifacts of both history and technology.

 In a Web 2.0 world, I suppose we would all be allowed (and encouraged) to add to this map, allowing it to evolve into the space  and depiction we could all agree is “just right” to describe it.

6 comments on “Chicken, Egg or Barnyard?

  1. Hi, good idea! Now I am the fun of your blog! Thank you for providing the name for Venn diagram, I was using “circles” in my blog, because I couldn’t remember the name: Venn diagram… I also don’t quite like the using of Venn diagram, because like you said, they Web2.0 and SM maybe chicken and eggs, different types of things, not just different chicken. Venn diagram is best suitable for illustrating the relation of inclusion of things of the same type. Cartography is a good idea! I came up with a soil and plants metaphor in my blog ( Welcome commenting!

  2. mbrownst says:

    What’s really interesting is that XKCD (web comic) had a similar idea about the Internet when diagramming it culturally:

  3. Mihaela says:

    I was going to point you to the same map Mike linked to 🙂

Looking forward to your thoughts and comments!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s